INIKA Organic Eye Pencil

A creamy, natural eye pencil designed for sensitive eyes — formulated with mineral pigments, botanical oils, and plant-derived waxes to deliver smooth, richly pigmented eyeliner without the use of harsh synthetics. This pencil glides on comfortably and is well-suited for daily wear on delicate skin.

Ingredients:

Formulated with octyldodecyl stearoyl stearate, Cocos nucifera (coconut) oil, C10–18 triglycerides, hydrogenated vegetable oil, Copernicia cerifera (carnauba) wax, Euphorbia cerifera (candelilla) wax, mica, polyglyceryl-3 diisostearate, oryzanol (rice-derived antioxidant complex), tocopherol (vitamin E), glyceryl caprylate, benzyl alcohol, and may contain (+/-) titanium dioxide (CI 77891) and iron oxides (CI 77499), depending on shade.

Certifications:

  • COSMOS Natural / Organic Certified

  • Certified Vegan

  • Certified Cruelty-Free

  • Halal Certified

These certifications provide added reassurance that ingredients are responsibly sourced, manufacturing is tightly controlled, animal testing is avoided, and contaminants such as heavy metals are monitored.

What I like:

  • Uses mineral pigments, botanical oils, and natural waxes instead of petrochemicals, parabens, or synthetic dyes.

  • Coconut oil, vitamin E, and plant waxes help nourish and protect the delicate eye area while delivering smooth glide.

  • Works well for sensitive eyes and reactive skin compared to conventional eyeliners.

  • Clean, low-tox formulation that avoids known high-risk cosmetic ingredients.

  • EWG rating: 3 — this score is driven by potential mineral contamination concerns, not because the formula contains intentionally added harmful ingredients. INIKA’s third-party certifications provide added assurance that heavy metals and unwanted toxins are tested for and controlled during sourcing and manufacturing.

Things to keep in mind:

  • Because the formula is creamy and oil-based, it may smudge more easily on oily lids — setting may help extend wear.

  • Contains benzyl alcohol, which can be mildly irritating for highly sensitive eyes — patch testing is important.

  • Natural formulas may not wear as long as conventional waterproof liners without a setting technique.

  • Color intensity can vary by shade due to mineral pigment composition.

Pregnancy / Breastfeeding Notes:

  • The mineral pigments, coconut oil, vegetable waxes, rice-derived oryzanol, and vitamin E are considered low risk for topical use during pregnancy and breastfeeding.

  • Carnauba and candelilla waxes are plant-based structural waxes and are considered safe for topical pregnancy use.

  • Benzyl alcohol, when used in very small cosmetic preservation amounts, is generally considered compatible with pregnancy in topical products, though those with extremely sensitive skin should take note.

  • This formula contains no retinoids, chemical dyes, or hormone-disrupting preservatives.

  • As always, patch testing is recommended, especially as eye sensitivity can increase during pregnancy and postpartum.